Welcome to Mark Barry's Review Blog - SOUNDS GOOD, LOOKS GOOD. It features in-depth reviews for Quality CD Reissues/Remasters - all with Discography Info (Amazon UK Top 10 Reviewer).
With over 1600 posts - genres covered include Rock, Pop, Soul, Funk, Jazz Fusion, Blues, Rhythm 'n' Blues, Doo Wop, Vocal Groups, 1960s and 1970s, Prog, Psych, Punk, New Wave, Reggae and more. I also extensively review Blu Rays issues for Modern and Classic Movies.
Rants, Raves and High Geekery.
Monday, 16 December 2013
"Cinema Paradiso" - A Review Of The 1988 Film And The December 2013 2-Disc BLU RAY 25th Anniversary Re-Issue.
*** THIS REVIEW IS FOR THE 2013 2-Disc 25th ANNIVERSARY BLU-RAY VERSION ***
Name-checked by the ludicrously-well-balanced readers of England's "The Guardian" newspaper in 2007 as their favourite-ever Foreign Language film - Giuseppe Tornatore's "Cinema Paradiso" was already the stuff of celluloid legend less than a decade after its release - and rightly so.
I remember the first time I saw it - I bawled my eyes out like a big girl's blouse - and it's been emblazoned in my heart and top five ever since. I make no bones about it - if "The Shawshank Redemption" is the greatest film ever made (and the absolute people's champ according to the IMDB database) - then "Cinema Paradiso" is the most 'beautiful' film ever made - and my number two with a bullet.
First aired in Italian cinemas in 1988 at 155-minutes - "Nuovo Cinema Paradiso" (its original title) was not well received at the box office. So edited down to a more manageable 123-minute length and given a shortened name - it was then re-presented by a terrified and weary Director at the Cannes Film Festival in 1989. The results were magical. The cast was literally cheered and applauded by hardened film critics as they walked from the screening to their hotel rooms. It won the Jury Prize at Cannes that year, then the Baftas, followed by the Oscars and subsequently garnished some twenty-plus awards in Europe alone (they run like a role of honour before the film starts)...
Told in flashback and subtitles - an elderly Italian lady phones her son in Rome who is now a big movie director. A local man has died and his funeral is the following day - she feels he must attend. Failing to get through - her daughter who is sat beside her mum reasons that maybe he's doesn't want to remember - after all he's been away from home for over 30 years? But as she dials again - mother insists - Salvatore will make an exception for Alfredo. When the middle-aged but still devilishly handsome Salvatore Di Vata lies on his pillow beside his beautiful young starlet partner in his suitably plush apartment - the camera closes in on his guilty face as he remembers who and what got him there...
And so the story begins - we're introduced to Salvatore as a precocious young 8-year old boy (nick-named Toto) who lives in the small Sicilian coastal town of Giancaldo. As his mother Maria stoically waits for her husband to return from the Russian Front of the Second World War - she darns socks and makes ends meet (subtly played by Antonella Attili). Meanwhile Toto sneaks away from his alter-boy duties with the town's priest - the hotheaded and sometimes comical Father Adelfio (brilliantly played by Leopoldo Trieste) to his real obsession - being with the wily old Alfredo in the projection booth of the local flick emporium 'Cinema Paradiso'. Childless himself, but big-hearted to a fault when it comes to the permanently inquisitive boy - Alfredo is a surrogate father to Toto and a hugely positive influence in the child's formative years (veteran French actor Philippe Noiret putting in a towering and endearing performance).
But more importantly - Alfredo makes Toto feel wonder. All those glamorous movie stars and the exotic locations they inhabit - their fabulous lives with all that possibility. Then there's the community who gather in the cinema - characters who spit - kids who drop spiders down the open mouths of sleeping patrons - hookers who sell their wares in the booth at the back. Onscreen there's Edward G Robinson gangsters - John Wayne cowboys - Charlie Chaplin comedians - gunshots followed by laughter (a few in the back seats of the cinema are timed to match those onscreen). And in between the feature films are newsreels that show war and horror and political change - but somewhere else. Then there's the really good stuff - like love and kissing and sex - if only the priest didn't vet it out with the shake of a bell ("Twenty-years! And I've never seen a kiss on screen!"). And as he peers out through the carved lion's mouth beneath the projection booth onto the gathered patrons below basking in that swirling combination of light and cigarette smoke - Toto gobbles it all up. Until one evening when Alfredo does the crowd a favour and the highly flammable film stock catches fire and changes the course of everyone's life...
Although accused of being a little over romanticised in places (young women wash their hair in fountains, happy kids carry books up school steps in glorious sunshine) - Tornatore is saying that this is an Italy of old where things seemed simpler. There are inkwells in school desks and children have their heads shaved in public to rid them of lice - but there's also laughter in the town square as people gather of an evening. And as the movie progresses with the decades - so some of that innocence and community is brutalized and lost (the final fate of the building itself, the town lunatic still prowling the square that no longer seems quirky but sad). "Cinema Paradiso" is also funny and poignant - a lot. The teacher banging the dullard kid's head against the chalk blackboard because he can't get his sums right - night-student Alfredo trying to skive answers off Toto as he sits an exam that only young children should be taking - the town lottery-winner who looks up at the burned-out shell of a building and thinks I can rebuild this...
But it's the relationship between Toto and Alfredo that drives the movie and is full of remembrances and sweetly observed moments. The scene where the child Toto rides in the basket on Alfredo's bike down the hill towards the town will make many think of the love they feel for their own parents. Toto then grows into a handsome 18-year-old who falls madly in love with a girl who gets off a bus as he's filming. Agnese Nano plays Elena and while Salvatore's initial advances are spurned, the beautiful Elena eventually comes around - only to have their love parted by fate and a banker father with other ideas for his daughter (their story as adults is considerably fleshed out in the extended 'Director's Cut'). Finally - the young Salvatore is told to leave this dead town and curdled past behind - go forward and create - never look back. Alfredo loves him enough to make the ultimate sacrifice - let him go - be his own man. The later half of the film is admitted very sad (especially the crushing of dreams) - but on it goes to an end-sequence that is quite possibly the best cinema has ever made (the celebrated ‘kissing’ sequence).
25th ANNIVERSARY ISSUE:
The 2009 single-disc BLU RAY contained the 'Theatrical Version' only and 'some' of the extras from the 2003 4-disc DVD box set. This new 2-disc “25th Anniversary Edition” BLU RAY UK released Monday 16 Dec 2013 (Barcode: 5027035010557) has both the 'Theatrical Version’ (124 minutes) and the ‘Director’s Cut’ (174 minutes) which extends the story massively - mainly concentrating on the older Toto and Elena and their relationship. The print has been literally frame-by-frame restored with the liner notes telling us that thousands of instances of hair, dirt and scratches have been removed with damaged frames fixed and density and stability issues corrected. The film was shot in European Widescreen which is 1.66:1 which means that on a modern widescreen TV - there’s small black bars on the left and right sides (they are very small and don’t really intrude that much). The audio is also majorly restored with both 5.1 and 2.0 mixes really bringing out the beauty of Ennio Morricone’s magnificent score and the Italian language film plays with English subtitles on the bottom of the screen (optional on or off). It's a bit lax to say the least that ENGLISH is the only Subtitle provided - but overall (given its lovely presentation) this is an exemplary handling of a recognised classic.
But as I suspected - picture-wise the results are both GORGEOUS and AWFUL. Filmed in 1988 on a less than monstrous budget - the wildly varying picture quality as locations jump and change is now ruthlessly shown up. One moment its glorious with shots of full on Sicilian summer sunshine - children running through the town square to school - the funeral procession on the hill with donkeys - Alfredo and Toto on the bike rolling down the hill - these are truly beautiful to look at. But once you get indoors the grain and fuzziness is incredible at times. The opening shot of the elderly mother phoning Salvatore is a perfect example - beautifully framed and now massively improved - but then it instantly turns to the daughter at the table - and the grain and picture disappears into an almost unwatchable fuzz. But I must stress this - I’ve seen this wonderful movie so many times - and at last “Cinema Paradiso” is truly shining like a diamond. It’s just that those expecting visual miracles here may be somewhat disappointed - and should allow for what they had to work with.
The outer glossy card wrap (so easy to smudge) is a lovely new take on Toto's wonderstruck face - it holds an inner 3-way foldout wallet with both discs housed in it. The inner 32-colour booklet is a joy to look at with new liner notes by Italian film expert PASQUALE IANNONE, stills of set outtakes, reproductions of the two posters and huge amounts of info on the cast, the film’s history and the restoration process.
Fans will recognise the “A Bear And A Mouse In Paradise” 27-minute feature from the 2009 BLU RAY - and a joy it is - interviews with cast and director - history of the film. But the new 52-minute documentary “A Dream Of Sicily” is odd to say the least. Although it features home footage from Director Tornatore - it’s mostly about him and Italian political corruption at the time and although it features clips from other movies (with Paradiso occasionally referenced) - it feels wildly out-of-place and self indulgent to a point where it’s a chore. There’s also the feeling that all Sicilians are stark raving mad - and that’s where they get their ‘dreamers’ quality from. I found the commentary by him and MILLICENT MARCUS to be much better and what I wanted.
The “Director’s Cut” is fabulous - with a huge amount of hole-filling scenes that focus on the young adult lovers Toto and Elena - and why they parted. It also shows how Alfredo truly set Toto free by pushing him out of Giancaldo to his destiny as a movie maker. I haven’t watched this long version in years but it was fab to return to it - especially looking this good.
Why does "Cinema Paradiso" resonate with audiences so much? I can't help but feel that it's the poignancy of the loss as much as the joy that touches us. Young love - young dreams - still fresh - still uncorrupted by life and its disappointments. The famous 'kissing' sequence that ends the movie sums it up best. It was apparently shown to the actor Jacques Perrin (who plays the adult Salvatore) without him knowing what he was going to see. His reactions of being blown away are real - and we in turn were exactly the same when we first saw it - blown away. Frankly Scarlett - if you're not in floods of tears by the time that sequence ends - check your pulse, you could already be dead...
"Cinema Paradiso" is a masterpiece - and sure this 25th Anniversary BLU RAY reissue of it is a little flawed (could have included the soundtrack lads) but I have to say that re-watching it looking all sparkly like this has been a joy for me. I cried like a sop again - and I wouldn't have it any other way.