"….Rub Gently To Release The Magic…"
1971 was huge for the Hippie Chanteuse who charmed the world with her warbly voice and beautiful smile (as a budding teen in 1971, I recall, the rest of her wasn't bad either). By the time she got to October 1971 and the release of her huge single "Brand New Key" – she had made No. 4 in the UK on the all-important singles charts and a staggering No.1 in America. The "Gather Me" LP it came off did well too – No. 15 in the States and one better at No. 14 in Blighty. Suddenly the ethereal Melanie was everywhere, and hip too.
And that’s where this stacked March 2026 twofer CD compilation containing a whopping four albums worth comes a scratch and sniff-in. There is a lot to unpack, so let's have at it…
UK released Friday, 3 March 2026 - "The Good Book/Gather Me/Garden In The City/Please Love Me" by MELANIE on Beat Goes On BGOCD1571 (Barcode 5017261215710) is a 43-Track Compilation that offers Four Seventies Albums Remastered across 2CDs and plays out as follows:
CD1 (66:27 minutes): 18 Tracks
1. Good Book [Side 1]
2. Babe Rainbow
3. Sign In The Window
4. The Saddest Thing
5. Nickle Song
6. Isn't it A Pity
7. My Father [Side 2]
8. Chords Of Fame
9. You Can Go Fishin'
10. Birthday Of The Rain
11. The Prize
12. Babe Rainbow (Reprise)
Tracks 1 to 12 are her fifth album "The Good Book" – released January 1971 in the USA on Buddah BDS 95000 and May 1971 in the UK on Buddah Records 2322 001. Produced by PETER SCHEKERYK – it peaked at No. 80 in the US Billboard LP charts and No. 9 on the UK LP charts. All songs by Melanie except Tracks 3, 7 and 8 by Bob Dylan, Judy Collins and Phil Ochs. Musicians include Hugh McCracken, Sol De Troia and Vinnie Bell on Guitars with Ron Frangipone on Keyboards and Eric Weissberg on Fiddle.
13. Little Bit Of Me [Side 1]
14. Some Day I'll Be A Farmer
15. Steppin'
16. Brand New Key
17. Ring Around The Moon
18. Ring The Living Bell: Shine The Living Light (Chant)/Ring The Living Bell/Shine The Living Light (Chant Reprise)
Tracks 13 to 18 are Side 1 of her sixth album "Gather Me" – released October 1971 in the UK on Buddah 2322 002 and October 1971 in the USA on Neighborhood NRS-47001. Produced by PETER SCHEKERYK – it peaked at No. 15 in the US Billboard LP charts and No. 14 on the UK LP charts. All songs by Melanie except two on Side 2 called "What Wondrous Love" and "Tell Me Why" which are a Traditional and a Forties Ballad by Micheal Edwards (often called "Tell Me Why (The Stars Do Shine)")
CD2 (75:25 minutes): 25 Tracks
1. Railroad [Side 2]
2. Kansas
3. Some Say (I Got Devil)
4. Center Of The Circle
5. What Wondrous Love
6. Baby Day
7. Tell Me Why
Tracks 1 to 7 are Side 2 of her sixth album "Gather Me" – released October 1971 in the UK on Buddah 2322 002 and October 1971 in the USA on Neighborhood NRS-47001. Produced by PETER SCHEKERYK – it peaked at No. 15 in the US Billboard LP charts and No. 14 on the UK LP charts. All songs by Melanie except two on Side 2 called "What Wondrous Love" and "Tell Me Why" which are a Traditional and a Forties Ballad by Micheal Edwards (often referred to as "Tell Me Why (The Stars Do Shine)")
8. Garden In The City [Side 1]
9. Love In My Mind
10. We Don't Know Where We're Going
11. Lay Lady Lay
12. Jig Saw Puzzle
13. Don't You Wait By The Water
14. Stop! I Don't Wanna Hear It Anymore
15. Somebody Loves Me
16. People In The Front Row
Tracks 8 to 16 are her seventh album "Garden In The City" – a Compilation of Earlier Outtakes and Soundtrack Rarities released November 1971 in the UK on Buddah 2318 054 and November 1971 in the USA on Buddah BDS 5095. Produced by PETER SCHEKERYK (except Tracks 10 and 14) – it peaked at No.19 in the UK LP. charts but didn't chart in the USA.
In September 1970 in the USA on Bell Records BELL 1203, the Soundtrack LP "R.P.M. (Revolutions Per Minute)" by Writers and Producers Barry DeVorzon and Perry Bodkin, Jr. contained two Melanie songs which are Tracks 10 and 14 above. These tunes were also repeated on the Spring of 1971 Euro-Only LP called "Please Love Me" (Germany on Buddah 2318 047) and on the eventual release in November 1973 in the UK of the "Please Love Me" LP which follows next. Because they are duplicates, BGO has not placed them twice on CD2. Guest Musicians include Toots Thielman on Harmonica, Sal De Troia on Guitars with Roger Kellaway on Keyboards.
17. Please Love Me [Side 1]
18. In The Hour
19. Getting Out
20. Momma, Momma
21. Save The Night
22. Please Love Me (Instrumental)
23. Ears To The Ground
24. Pebbles In The Sand
25. God's Only Daughter
Tracks 17 to 25 are the UK LP variant of the 1971 European LP of the same name "Please Love Me" – released November 1973 in the UK on Buddah 2318 047
The Outer Card Slipcase protects the 2CD jewel case inside while a jam-packed 24-page booklet gives a huge career overview by longtime contributor to BGO booklets – JOHN O'REGAN. O'Regan moves from her iconic Woodstock appearance in 1969 (where America embraced her) through the early Seventies milestone songs like "What Have They Done to My Song Ma" and "Lay Down (Candles In The Rain)" and of course to these albums. With quiet Acoustic passages, sweeping strings and her wailing warbling voice – new 2026 Remasters from ANDREW THOMPSON do a fab job (even with those Sixties throwbacks on the iffy compilation "Garden In The City").
18. In The Hour
19. Getting Out
20. Momma, Momma
21. Save The Night
22. Please Love Me (Instrumental)
23. Ears To The Ground
24. Pebbles In The Sand
25. God's Only Daughter
Tracks 17 to 25 are the UK LP variant of the 1971 European LP of the same name "Please Love Me" – released November 1973 in the UK on Buddah 2318 047
The Outer Card Slipcase protects the 2CD jewel case inside while a jam-packed 24-page booklet gives a huge career overview by longtime contributor to BGO booklets – JOHN O'REGAN. O'Regan moves from her iconic Woodstock appearance in 1969 (where America embraced her) through the early Seventies milestone songs like "What Have They Done to My Song Ma" and "Lay Down (Candles In The Rain)" and of course to these albums. With quiet Acoustic passages, sweeping strings and her wailing warbling voice – new 2026 Remasters from ANDREW THOMPSON do a fab job (even with those Sixties throwbacks on the iffy compilation "Garden In The City").
Fans will notice that the missing link here is her fifth 1971 outing and a popular title in the UK – the Soundtrack LP "All The Right Noises" issued July 1971 on Buddah 2318 034 (August 1971 in the USA). About a hip family down by the Seaside trying to make ends meet and starring the gorgeous Olivia Hussey, the Soundtrack had 17 songs, 16 Melanie originals and one Traditional cover version. Perhaps BGO will get to that next time.
Speaking of missing bits, the "Please Love Me" LP has a convoluted history worth explaining too - initially a European-Only album first released spring of 1971 in Germany, Austria and Spain (Buddah 2318 047 in Germany) – it did not chart (some copies were simply called Love Me). The 1971 Euro LP "Please Love Me" contained two Melanie songs "We Don't Know Where We're Going" and "Stop! I Don’t Wanna Hear It Anymore" that first appeared on a US Soundtrack LP in September 1970 called "R.P.M. (Revolutions Per Minute)" by Perry Botkin, Jr. and Peter DeVorzon. Melanie is also credited as a composer on Bell Records BELL 1203 (the film featured Anthony Quinn, Ann-Margaret and Gary Lockwood). Never one to miss out on more Melanie product, Buddah finally issued the LP November 1973 in the UK on Buddah 2318 090. Blighty copies of "Please Love Me" however used different artwork to the 12-Track 1971 German issue, dropped one tune and re-jiggered the song sequence for the remaining 11. The missing song is "All The Right Noises (Instrumental)" which is not on this double unfortunately (so you could sequence both variants of the LP) - it is available on the "All The Right Noises" soundtrack LP from July 1971. This 2CD BGO set also does not repeat the songs "We Don't Know Where We're Going" and "Stop! I Don't Wanna Hear It Anymore" for the "Please Love Me" set because they already appear in the Garden In The City album (Tracks 10 and 14 on CD2).
To the music and what we have…
"…Give the poet a poem and the singer a song, they’ll tell us they love us so we don’t feel alone..." she sings on the lovely piano and chorus singa-long opener "The Good Book". Hiss accompanies "Babe Rainbow" – but it soon settles into a quietly savage attack on the physical demands of the media to look good every second of the day (afraid to walk down the street). Thinking of today’s celebrities and their scrutiny cells, Melanie must have known 55-years ago what it meant physically and mentally to be lumbered with looks that stop men in their tracks (keep your glow on). The first of three cover versions is Bob Dylan – clearly enamoured with his "New Morning" LP from the year before (1970) – Melanie does a lovely organ-lead take on "Sign In The Window" – the lyrics about searching for peace in a rural setting appealing. The rabble-rouser "Nickel Song" (the January 1972 US 45 on Buddah BUD 628 that followed the huge hit Brand New Key from late 1971) might have been fun back in the day but in 2026 it’s a more than difficult to take. More misery in the second cover - "My Father" - a Judy Collins tune from 1969 on Elektra Records that longs to live in France – anywhere but Smallville. The third and last cover is by Phil Ochs - "Chords Of Fame" regaling the tale of a Troubadour trying to be a star only find that whiskey and music is all he has left once the lights have faded. Country Acoustic rhythms slither in with "You Can Go Fishin'" – the home domestics and gambling soon bolstered up with a rolling piano from Ron Frangipone with Eric Weissberg on Fiddle (nicely Remastered). The quiet introspective nature of "The Good Book" continues with "The Prize" – another attack on her being the trophy while some man grins on the sidelines counting the dollars.
After the downer-feel to "The Good Book" (produced by her husband and Neighborhood Records founder Peter Schekeryk) – her truly big-album arrived in October 1971 on both sides of the pond. "Gather Me" was preceded with the monster crowd-pleasing fun that was/is "Brand New Key" – a Buddah and Neighborhood Records 45 that smashed to No.1 in the USA and No.4 in the UK. The LP had the feel of a major voice finding her groove – tunes and lyrics scoring – songs like the witty "Some Day I'll Be A Farmer" where Melanie is building and climbing a mountain that is not there. "Steppin'" is a cool tune and the audio on "Brand New Key" is fantastic (pairs of roller-skates) while Side 1 ends in the ambitious/excellent triple-part "Ring The Living Bell" – big lyrics about big spiritual subjects complete with spiralling Gospel-type vocal choruses, church organ and gushing strings. Side 2 opens with the heavily orchestrated "Railroad" – screaming about the road getting in the way and friends who did stupid self-harm things to rocking bands. One of her lovelier songs – the la-la of "Center Of The Circle" pleads for lovers and friends to understand until she gets it together somewhere down the road (nice audio too as those Brass and Strings do battle half-way through). Two covers are massively re-worked into Melanie songs towards the end of the "Gather Me" album – the Gospel oh-my-soul Traditional "What Wondrous Love" (beautiful string arrangements) while a Forties crooner ballad "Tell Me Why" ends things in high acoustic+voice romance (I will tell why I love you). Impressive stuff and you can feel why the LP is such a fan fave.
"Garden In The City" opens with a retro-60s glockenspiel sound and fans soon work out this is a step back and not forward – the LP being peddled as a New Melanie album is in fact a collection of earlier outtakes and rare Soundtrack songs. "Love Is My Mind" slinks in with only an Acoustic Guitar and a lone violin – the Remaster clearly trying to contain tape noise rather well. The 1970 Bell Records "R.P.M. (Revolutions Per Minute)" Soundtrack song "We Don't Know Where We're Going" is a lovely Acoustic ballad ala Uni Records Neil Diamond with sweeping strings and oboes a fluttering. Time for a Bob Dylan cover in "Lay Lady Lay" – but again its very Sixties production and feel gives the game away as not quite being singer-songwriter kosher in late 1971. Cheap photos creep in for "Don't You Wait By The Water" – an angry screecher that feels like a Demo you want to shelve. The other RPM soundtrack tune is "Stop! I Don't Wanna Hear It Any More" – an army marcher complete with confederates penny-whistle and da-da-da-da vocals – very dated by 1971. The lonesome "Somebody Loves Me" is staggeringly close to the emotional bone – Melanie wondering which guy that passes by is her baby – the one that is meant-to-be. A patchy album romps to another Sixties reject close with "People In The Front Row" and you can see why this LP is on sale for £1.
The release schedule of the fourth LP on offer here has been explained above – to the tunes… Buddah Records milked her output – much you suspect to her artistic detriment. Released in the UK in late 1973, its 1971 material explains why her commercial impact fell off an out-of-time cliff after 1972 (especially in England where she never charted again). What was good in 1971 was old-hat by the next year and the year after as Rock moved fast and Melanie seemed to remain in the same type of song rut. Melancholy is keeping company with Leonard Cohen for the sad "In The Hour" – but far better is a powerhouse "Momma, Momma". I live in this world but I am really dying instead - her passionate moaning delivery is all-in and you either dig in or turn off. "Save The Night" is a sad wife song – longing to slip away – longing to save something other than face. The 1973 UK LP ends with three well-produced life-must-change anthems - "Pebbles In The Sand" being the prettiest hippie amongst the lot.
Fans will love "The Good Book" and its follow-up "Gather Me" – two nuggets from an extraordinary year for Melanie Safka (1971). But the two compilation sets after it are patchy to say the least – and worse - feel wildly out of place. Sure, there are lovely moments on both "Garden In The City" and "Please Love Me" but the truth is they were and are thin on the ground.
Still, this is another stellar release from Beat Goes On – a wallop of material for fans to dig and in typically cool presentation/spiffing audio. Melanie Safka passed in 2024 – classy to the end – RIP lovely lady…
%20Mine%20Front%20Slv.jpeg)
%20Mine%20Inners%201%20of%202.jpeg)
%20Mine%20Inners%202%20of%202.jpeg)
%20Mine%20Rear%20Slv.jpeg)
%20Mine%20Front%20Slv.jpeg)
%20Mine%20Inners%201%20of%202.jpeg)
%20Mine%20Inners%202%20of%202.jpeg)
%20Mine%20Rear%20Slv.jpeg)
%20Mine%20Front%20Slv.jpeg)
%20Mine%20Inners%201%20of%207%20-%20Booklet%20and%204%20Card%20Slvs%20Spread.jpeg)
%20Mine%20Rear%20Slv.jpeg)
%20Mine%20Inners%206%20of%207%20-%20First%20Text%20Page%20in%20Booklet.jpeg)
%20Mine%20Inners%207%20of%207%20-%20Inner%20Spread%20Pages%20of%20Booklet%20with%20Memorabilia.jpeg)
%20Mine%20Inners%202%20of%207%20-%20Stereo%20Death%20Breakdown%20Card%20for%201968%20LP.jpeg)
.jpg)
%20Mine%20Inners%203%20of%207%20-%20Royal%20York%20Crescent%20Card%20for%201970%20LP.jpeg)
%20Mine%20Inners%204%20of%207%20-%20A%20Vulture%20Is%20Not%20A%20Bird%20You%20Can%20Trust%20Card%20for%201971%20LP.jpeg)
%20Mine%20Inners%205%20of%207%20-%20Singer%20Sleeps%20On%20As%20Blaze%20Rages%20Card%20for%201972%20LP.jpeg)
%20Mine%20Front%20Slv.jpeg)
%20Mine%20Inners%201%20of%207.jpeg)
%20Mine%20Rear%20Slv.jpeg)
%20Mine%20Inners%202%20of%207.jpeg)
%20Mine%20Inners%203%20of%207.jpeg)
%20Mine%20Inners%204%20of%207.jpeg)
%20Mine%20Inners%205%20of%207.jpeg)
%20Mine%20Inners%206%20of%207.jpeg)
%20Mine%20Inners%207%20of%207.jpeg)
.jpeg)